Chapter 6: Principles of ecology
ULTIMATE AND PROXIMATE CAUSALITY, HOW VERSUS WHY
So far we have discussed how the cause underlying biological phenomena can be rooted both in events occurring at the next lower scale of organization, as well as interactions with factors at the same or higher scales of organization. These two different forms of causality result from principle of emergent properties in biological organization, and represent the fundamental difference between reductionist and holistic philosophies of scientific inquiry. Another way that these two approaches are described is by the terms ultimate and proximate causality. The proximate cause is the mechanism that allows for something to happen, and the ultimate cause is the drive that makes it happen. These can be summarized as how (proximate cause) and why (ultimate cause). Within in the context of biology, the proximate cause is nearly always the reductionist explanation from the next lower scale. The ultimate cause is the conditions in the environment that place certain constraints on the organisms, and the selection based drive for the organisms to survive in the context of that environment and their interactions with other organisms. The following is an illustration of now ultimate and proximate causality work together to explain the biology of some desert rodents of North America kangaroo rats and pocket mice.
Why don't kangaroo rats drink water? This will be the question around which we demonstrate the concepts of ultimate and proximate causality in biology; note that this question occurs at the scale of an individual organism. Kangaroo rats are small rodents adapted to life in the desert. Like many desert creatures they live in burrows underground during the day to escape the desert heat (and predators), and they are active at night. They have both longer life spans and slower reproductive rates than typical rodents of their size, which is probably an adaptation to the unpredictable food supply and harsh conditions of the desert. These animals eat predominantly seeds, which they gather in fur-filled pouches on either side of their mouth. They store these seeds in caches, from which they can later feed for many months. This seed caching behavior is also an adaptation to the low productivity and unpredictability of desert ecosystems. These animals are predominantly found in the very arid areas of North America, including parts of the desert that get less than 5 inches of rain on average per year, with dry years that can be as low as 1 inch per year (or less!). For the most part, therefore, there is little standing water available to them because even most streams are dry in most of the year. When these animals are kept in captivity in research labs they commonly do not drink water that is given to them and have even been known to bury their water dishes with sand. It should be noted, however, that the dozen or so species of kangaroo rat do vary somewhat in their ability to live without water.
Explanations for why kangaroo rats do not have to drink water can be found at all the scales of biological organization, and all of them are correct. First we will look to lower scales of biological organization for explanation. Kangaroo rats have unusually large kidneys that allow them to remove nearly all of the water from their urine before excretion (Schmidt-Nielsen 1997). This is the result of an elongated loop of Henle within the kidneys, which in turn are the result of genes that code for proteins that form those structures. Kangaroo rats are also very efficient at utilizing water that they literally produce as a byproduct of carbohydrate metabolism from other cellular processes, and they preferentially eat seeds that have higher carbohydrate levels and lower protein levels. These explanations on the physiological, cellular, and genetic scales all qualify as proximate causes for the fact that kangaroo rats do not need to drink water. This is also a reductionist approach to explaining a biological phenomenon on the organismal scale.
What about explanations at and above the scale of the organism itself? These start with the classic natural selection argument that the reason that kangaroo rats do not need to drink water is that those animals that are less dependent on standing water have a higher probability of surviving and reproducing in desert conditions. Through time natural selection should favor those individuals that were more drought tolerant, and hence eventually led to the evolution of species that do not need to drink standing water at all. This process occurs because of interactions between individuals of the same species, so evolution by natural selection is a population scale explanation, one scale higher. We can also look for explanations on yet higher scales. Given that the desert is a stressful environment, why are kangaroo rats even living there at all? Why are they not living in a place with more rainfall, so that they would not have to have all these special adaptations that allow them to live without drinking water? The answer to this question is on the community scale of biological organization.
The reason kangaroo rats live in an environmentally extreme habitat is competition with other species of rodents. Kangaroo rats presumably could survive in many more productive habitats that have more food and water. However, there are other species in those habitats that are better competitors under those less stressful conditions, probably in large part because they are faster reproducers. Trade-offs exist between different species traits, so the very traits that allow a kangaroo rats to thrive in the desert may not make them good competitors under less arid conditions. The long life spans and slow reproductive rates that are adaptive in the harsh, unpredictable desert environment would result in lower reproduction and therefore lower competitive ability is less harsh environments. Furthermore, the energy invested in the physiological structures, such as enormous kidneys, that allow for kangaroo rats to live without standing water is energy that will not be invested in reproduction. Therefore, one reason why kangaroo rats do not need to drink water is lack of interspecific competition (competition between species), which is a community scale explanation.
It is also possible to find an explanation for why kangaroo rats do not need to drink water at the global biosphere scale. If there were no deserts in North America to begin with, then there would be no need for kangaroo rats to be so drought tolerant. There are deserts in North America because of the nature of the Hadley cell global circulation patterns, which create deserts around the world at approximately 30° latitudes. This is discussed in much more detail in Chapter 3, but suffice it to say that if these global circulation patterns did not exist, the deserts of North America would be greatly reduced (recall that the Great Basin is a rainshadow desert, so it likely would still be present in this imaginary Hadley cell-free world), and at the very least we would expect fewer species of kangaroo rats, or perhaps none at all.
PROXIMATE AND ULTIMATE CAUSALITY IN YOUR LIFE
The concepts of ultimate and proximate causality also are relevant to situations other than biology. For example, imagine that you have an internship at a government agency in Sacramento (which, by the way, is a great opportunity available to UC Davis students), and that you are on the Yolo Causeway driving your car to work. If we were to ask the question "what is causing you to drive to Sacramento?" we could give different explanations based on proximate versus ultimate causes. The proximate cause behind your driving to Sacramento is the workings of your car engine, because the fact that it is burning gasoline and turning chemical energy into mechanical and kinetic energy is what is causing you to move toward Sacramento. In other words, this proximate cause explains how you are driving to Sacramento. The ultimate cause considers why you are driving to Sacramento. It starts by looking at the benefits to you as an individual for going to your job; you are driving to Sacramento because you need to make money, and because you are gaining valuable job experience to help your future career. Of course, there are larger-scale ultimate causes in addition to this, such as that you are fulfilling a role in the government agency, and that agency is in turn fulfilling a role in the governing of California that was deemed important by policy makers. If any of these ultimate or proximate causes did not exist, such as if the car engine did not work, if you did not benefit as an individual from the job, or if the agency had no need for your labor, then you would not be driving to Sacramento. Notice that the proximate causes focus on smaller scale explanations, such as the mechanics of your car, while the ultimate cause are larger scale, such as your individual economic needs and the existence of the job to begin with. The parallels with the ultimate and proximate causes in the kangaroo rat example should be readily apparent.
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW TO BE A PRINCIPLED ECOLOGIST
In summary, some of the general principles of ecology presented in this essay are as follows:
- Ecology focuses on the biological scales of the individual organism as well as larger scales, including populations, communities, ecosystems, and the biosphere.
- The principle of emergent properties states that while each successively larger scale is composed of the units of the next smaller scale, it possesses properties unique to that scale.
- Causal explanations can occur at scales smaller than, the same as, or larger than the scale of the observed phenomenon.
- Causes at smaller scales are called reductionist or mechanistic explanations, and are examples of proximate causality.
- Causes at the same or larger scales are called holistic explanations or emergent phenomena, and are examples of ultimate causality.
- Essentially all species, including wildlife, in ecological systems are dependent upon other species for their existence.
- In spite of this interdependence, the organisms within ecological systems nearly always act to maximize their individual fitness, not to benefit the population, community or ecosystem.
- Constant change is a commonality of all levels of organization in ecology.
- Ecosystems are altered by human manipulations of the environment and these changes are often irreversible.
The following chapters will give you more detailed information of principles in population, community, and ecosystem ecology that will be quite useful for studying wildlife, and for understanding the consequences of human alterations of natural systems.
Table of Contents
1. Roots of the modern environmental dilemma: A brief history of the relationship between humans and wildlife
2. A history of wildlife in North America
3. Climatic determinants of global patterns of biodiversity
5. Natural selection
6. Principles of ecology
7. Niche and habitat
8. Conservation biology
9. Conservation in the USA: legislative milestones
10. Alien invaders
11. Wildlife and Pollution
12. What you can do to save wildlife
Feedback & Citation
Start or join a discussion below about this page or send us an email to report any errors or submit suggestions for this page. We greatly appreciate all feedback!
Help Protect and Restore Ocean Life
Help us protect and restore marine life by supporting our various online community-centered marine conservation projects that are effectively sharing the wonders of the ocean with millions each year around the world, raising a balanced awareness of the increasingly troubling and often very complex marine conservation issues that affect marine life and ourselves directly, providing support to marine conservation groups on the frontlines that are making real differences today, and the scientists, teachers and students involved in the marine life sciences. Join us today or show your support with a monthly donation. Join the MarineBio Conservation Society With your support, most marine life and their ocean habitats can be protected, if not restored to their former natural levels of biodiversity. We sincerely thank our thousands of members, donors and sponsors, who have decided to get involved and support the MarineBio Conservation Society.