25th February 2010

Keep wild animals wild – they’re not circus freaks

posted under Marine Conservation |

The death of Dawn Brancheau in Orlando was tragic and my heart goes out to her family and friends. I understand it was her dream since the first time she visited SeaWorld to train marine mammals and I imagine she loved what she did. We get dozens of emails from our MarineBio members and other readers who talk about their dreams of becoming marine mammal trainers. They love whales and dolphins. I do too. I love them so much I’m willing to give up seeing them up close in an aquarium. Because I know they are happiest in the wild where they belong. When they’re contained in an unnatural environment they cannot follow their inborn instincts to swim long distances, hunt for prey, travel in pods and enjoy a healthy social life with their families in the wild.

orca or killer whales, Orcinus orcaThis tragedy is a loud message – whales and dolphins belong in the wild. If you love them, see them on BBC Blue Planet where they’ve been beautifully filmed in their natural habitat. Go see them for yourself in the wild. But don’t support keeping them in captivity. What if you were taken out of your home and confined to a 4′ x 4′ room? You’d probably go a little nutty after awhile too.

Dawn’s death was tragic, but keeping these animals in captivity and forcing them to perform tricks for food is tragic too. They don’t do flips and give fin rides because they’re having fun. They do it for food. I don’t believe for a second that they’re having fun. They’re being tortured in a way – to the delight and applause of crowds worldwide.

Whales and dolphins are majestic wild creatures and they should stay that way. If they’re kept in captivity for rehabilitation or temporarily for research – okay. But to keep them prisoners is just plain wrong.

My hope is that this was “Shamu’s” final show. It would be the greatest gift Dawn could ever give to her beloved marine mammals.

And to the media: Killer whales are dolphins, not whales. Family: Delphinidae

Share

There are currently 4 responses to “Keep wild animals wild – they’re not circus freaks”

Why not let us know what you think by adding your own comment! Your opinion is as valid as anyone elses, so come on... let us know what you think.

  1. 1 On February 27th, 2010, Victoria said:

    I totaly agree with this website. If you disagree, go to youtube and watch them in aquariums. Then watch them in thier natural habitat. I am only twelve and I know the difference between happiness and being forced to do some thing for an audience for food. If I was that whale I would feel like a complete idiot. Rethink your opinion of having whales captive.

  2. 2 On March 3rd, 2010, Rahul said:

    Well said Victoria!

  3. 3 On March 4th, 2010, Natasha said:

    Why should we make this whale perform for us? If we let him out into the wild he is just going to die anyways. Well, not right away, but within the next couple months or so. If they chose to kill the whale now, he will not have to suffer the consequences of dying by himself without family to comfort him.

  4. 4 On March 12th, 2010, Amanda said:

    It is entirely possible this Orca’s calls could be played near pods he is thought to belong to to see if a reaction can be seen and/or heard. It may merit some efforts to reunite them, considering these animals stay with their family pods for life.

    I have heard that his teeth are fairly worn, however I have also heard that Keiko’s were far worse.

    He was not born in captivity. He belongs with his pod. He’s too big to even be kept in the larger tank @ Seaworld Orlando. If the concern is for breeding, then freeze some of his “gift” and send him home.

Leave a Reply

  • Get Notified

  • Enter email:

  • July 2010
    M T W T F S S
    « Jun    
     1234
    567891011
    12131415161718
    19202122232425
    262728293031  

Join the MarineBio Conservation Society